Essays · How dogs work
They have not turned on you. They have told you something true, and the worst thing you can do is punish them for saying it.
About five minutes
The call usually comes with shock in it. He growled at me. Over a chew. He has never done that.
The shock is the problem, because it produces the response that makes everything worse.
A dog has something valuable and is worried about losing it. That is the entire thing. It is not dominance, it is not a bid for control of the household, and it is not a preview of the dog turning on the children.
It is also completely normal. Almost every dog will guard something under the right conditions, and the reason most people never see it is that the right conditions have not happened yet.
The growl is not the problem. The growl is the dog choosing to warn you instead of biting you, which is the best available outcome in that moment.
Dog growls. Person is shocked and frightened. Person tells the dog off, or takes the item, or does both.
The dog learns two things. Growling gets punished. And the thing I was worried about, losing the item, is exactly what happened.
Do that a few times and the growl disappears, which everybody reads as the problem being solved. What has actually happened is that the warning has been deleted while the worry remains.
The next escalation after a deleted growl is a bite with no warning, and the household will say it came out of nowhere. It did not. Somebody removed the part that was coming from somewhere.
Stop moving. Do not take the item. Do not tell them off.
Go and get something better, come back, and trade. Put the good thing down at a distance, let them come off the item, and pick it up while they are eating. That is not rewarding the growl. The growl has already happened and the interval is long enough that you are teaching a different lesson entirely.
The lesson is that people approaching an item means better items arrive. That is the whole treatment and it works in most households inside a few weeks.
Walk past your dog while they eat and drop something good in the bowl. Do it for the first year. Not every meal, just often enough.
You are building a dog who looks up when you approach food and expects something good. A dog with that history does not develop the problem in the first place.
The old advice of taking the bowl away to show them who is boss does the exact opposite. It teaches the dog that people near food means food disappears, which is precisely the belief you are trying to avoid installing.
If a bite has connected. If the guarding is over locations rather than objects, especially furniture near a person. If it is directed at a child. If it has escalated in the last month.
Those cases are still workable and they are not cases to manage from a webpage. Get a person in the room.
Your dog is not asserting anything about the hierarchy. Your dog found something they value and got worried, and rather than going straight to teeth, they told you.
That is a dog with functioning brakes and a working communication system. Both of those are worth protecting, and both are what gets destroyed when the first response is anger.
If you would rather just ask someone
Tell us the age, what is happening, and what you have already tried. You will get a straight answer about what we would do, whether or not that involves us.
More in How dogs work
Your dog is not being stubborn
Stubborn is the word people reach for when they cannot see what the dog is actually responding to. It is almost always wrong and it decides what you do next.
How dogs workYour dog told you three times before it happened
Almost nothing comes out of nowhere. The signals were there and they were quiet, and quiet signals are the ones people are worst at seeing.
How dogs workExcited and stressed look the same from the outside
Bouncing, whining, mouthing, spinning. People read one as happy and one as a problem, and the dog is often in the same state for both.